In order to post comments you have to be a registered member and be logged in.
If you dont have an account click here to create an account.
If you already have an account click here to login.
1 By jake-the-mus 2007-01-30 Well...All I can say about the skills is that silencer would own you in a lane....And also base STR is too high and maybe the base attack speed is too. Other than that good hero.... 2 By jake-the-mus 2007-01-30 Sorry for double post but you say he can't activate an item? what if he has a staff of wizardry or a sheep stick or something witih intel and also satanic is an active item....Yes and i forgot your ultimate is WAY too cheap....your team will never be able to get ganked it will ruin the game... 3 By nthomas5143 2007-01-30 @Jake-the-mus. I made his strength higher than most due to the fact that he has no intel. And yes he can gain intel from items and activate them, but its not recommended because the mp gained may not even be enough to activate the ability. As for his ultimate i am willing to take alternate suggestions. (Like make it a active abil?) 4 By Daelin 2007-01-30 I'm totally against such unconventional heroes. They tend to shake the balance of the whole game (usually can be abused one way or another). I do not know DotA heroes so well to give practical examples but I'm certain that there are. But it's nice that you try to come with original stuff. Quite a lot of auras though, don't ya think? 5 By nthomas5143 2007-01-30 @Dealin. NONE of his abilities are auras if that was the impression. They only effect him not his allies. 6 By nthomas5143 2007-01-30 @Dealin. NONE of his abilities are auras if that was the impression. They only effect him not his allies. 7 By IchirakuRamen 2007-01-30 Yo that hero seems fun to play, but I think the ultimate should be changed, maybe to a less sight range instead of the whole map 8 By c_r_a_c_k 2007-01-30 Roy, you fukbag. This isn't a good hero.
9 By LETHAL 2007-02-03 c_r_a_c_k wrote it: "...but specific heroes that counter specific heroes is not what DotA should be about. Heroes can counter each other, but not in every way." Hmmm...have you ever seen a match with OBSIDIAN DESTROYER vs. WARLOCK? I had a match,when I played Harbringer,and after the Warlock got a Refresher Orb,and summoned 2 Infernals,I destroyed BOTH with 4 shots (and after this the Warlock too,of course)... 10 By Shimrra_3 2007-02-03 I don't know, Ult seems a wee bit imba, maybe 1000/1500/2000 instead. Silent Heart is way too good regardless of ANYTHING ELSE. 30% movespeed?? Lycan has 12% and look where that gets him. Honestly... Mmmm an all passive hero is sorta low. 11 By c_r_a_c_k 2007-02-03 Quoting LETHAL: "Hmmm...have you ever seen a match with OBSIDIAN DESTROYER vs. WARLOCK? I had a match,when I played Harbringer,and after the Warlock got a Refresher Orb,and summoned 2 Infernals,I destroyed BOTH with 4 shots (and after this the Warlock too,of course)... (Arcane Orb = +400 damage to summoned units!) So in DOTA there are NOT EVERY HERO EQUALENT!!!"
12 By Shimrra_3 2007-02-03 Guys, why don't you keep private conflicts out of an innocent and unrelated chat room... 13 By PibeArg 2007-02-04 nice hero man.. just that i would modify that 3000 AOE, it is too much..
14 By PibeArg 2007-02-04 nice hero man.. just that i would modify that 3000 AOE, it is too much..
15 By Daelin 2007-02-04 I was strictly refering to the visual effect (SFX) "A Red/Green/Light Blue Aura appears around Whisper.". Oh yeah, *Silent Heart* is overpowered. Check Lifestealer's Anabolic Frenzy. It gives ONLY attack speed (10/20/30/40%) and movement speed (3/5/7/9%). Or Razor's Unholy Frevor (3/5/8/10% movement and 0.5/1/1.5/2 HP/sec). Your ability's bonuses are greater than those of both the abilities, and moreover, it not only combines them, but also gives evasion. This is soooo overpowered. *Quiet strike* in my opinion is not original at all (refering overall to warcraft spells, not only to DotA). *One in All* is pretty neat. Does it grant true sight (can invisible units be spotted with this ability?) 16 By khailor 2007-02-04 Isn't silent heart too powerful. Compare it to DK's ability. Doesn't this win in every facet? 17 By nthomas5143 2007-02-04 Thanks for the comments, im gonna edit the aoe of his ult, and reduce the movespeed bonus. But @Daelin Whispers Ult only lets u see the colored dots on the minimap, not the actual character so yes you can know where invisible units are u just cant see them or attack them. 18 By dOtA-AlLsTAr 2007-02-04 yea that ulti... not cool, even after you changed it to an AoE. You'll almost NEVER die. yea, maybe making it an active spell, but then that would kill the whole "all passive" situation. well do try to do something about the ulti 19 By gamer_anthony 2007-02-05 First I have a question about the ulti. Does it give vision to just you the player or to the team as a whole. Now if you are still taking ideas for the ulti, instead of seeing all heroes minimap icons could it be that you gain the minimap icons of the last 3 heroes to attack you. At least that way there is still some way to counter him. If it still needs nerfed after that it could give a mark to the players you can see so the two that you can't could get you easier. 20 By gamer_anthony 2007-02-05 Sorry for the double post. More questions about the ulti. Do you take damage if an ally dies? Also, if you are playing as Whisper what happens if your ulti kills you? I mean besides dying does anyone get gold because somehow someone killed you. Lastly, If you are killing a hero as Whisper and you have less health than the damage your ulti does what happens to you and the gold for your death? 21 By lupeman 2007-02-05 he cant be killed if he gets his ulti then --_--... thats kinda gay that u dont hav any spells that use mana 22 By koobefil_89 2007-02-06 i think the first spell is imba.. i mean at level 4 u get EVADE, SPEED and REGEN at the same time?? Wow. In my opinion, i think that Silent Heart shud be the ulti.. 23 By karuma 2007-02-06 nice concept on the ulti but the AoE? is it that suppose to be that big? like stygwyr's thirst but bigger. cool hero concept.. im gonna give it an 8/10 24 By nthomas5143 2007-02-06 Thanks for the ideas guys. To answer your questions, yes you get hurt for allies deaths, and if you die from your ult its like techies suicide. Nobody gets gold, and you dont lose any but you must wait for your respawn. And only you can see the enemies and as i said before its only on the minimap, you cannot actually see the character. @gamer_anthony i liked the idea of the last heroes to attack you. I change it to the last heros to attack you for X seconds. and increase the length per level. And @Koobifil_89 im not sure if you read the post that i am gonna nerf silent hearts move speed. 25 By Trigg3r 2007-02-09 THIS IS TOO CHEAP 26 By BenjiMan 2007-02-09 this hero is good and bad, good is that the spells have kinda good effects 27 By Creative_PH 2007-02-10 ALL OF THIS CHARACTERS SKILLS ARE CHEATING EVERY SINGLE ONE OF THEM all skills are cheating first kill shud be 5%movement increase 10%aspd increase 1sec regen and no evasion and ulti oh god no ofens but its imposible for this char to be accepted impossible.... oh yah and he is immortal at level 16 28 By CIA(bug-guy) 2007-02-10 The idea for the hero is really good but I feel the passives seem way to powerful, with correct items this hero could be way to over powered, overall really unique idea 29 By ejcena 2007-02-12 Gud hero a balance hero because many items do not stack god job i give u a 1 thumbs up! 30 By DOTA_filth 2007-02-12 This hero idea is NIFTY, however, being nifty does not justify GODLIKE ABILITIES. Silent strike combined with silent heart?REDICULOUS. With power treads and midas this guy could own anything mid game. ANYTHING. Also, one with all, the idea is neat, but its still imba to the max. Sure you can "only see the dots". But who in their right mind wouldnt flee when they see three or four dots on teh mini map gunning for them? The range on that needs to be SERIOUSLY nerfed. But other than that, NIFTY 31 By Coke 2007-02-13 Wordless defense and ult are imbalanced, but he's alright. 32 By ncc1701 2007-02-14 Ultumat is not bad but it needs some thing.Well good idea. 33 By archmedi 2007-02-17 A nice addition to the Sentinels !!! but maybe lessen his ulti skill 1500/2000/2500 is enough. His skills are good and i hope this hero will be enabled to play in DotA later on. 34 By Scytale 2007-02-18 Umm Nice Hero but i wish that the silent heart be reduced or make it an activated ability for no mana cost with cooldown. I mean, i can see night stalker running but thats only half of the time. This is all OF THE TIME!! Well nice hero but i wish that he had a chance to blink ^^" 35 By jacked143 2007-02-19 Lol some stats on speed. With Boots
36 By donchovi 2007-02-20 as soon as i saw that this hero had no man abilities and all passive moves i was really shocked. i don't know if this hero will work in dota. i mean int is a part of the game. i mean some of these abilities can take mana per second or something, they don't have to have like a cooldown effect. 37 By seductas 2007-02-23 lol him against obsidian XD
38 By Shimrra_3 2007-02-23 Nerf Silent Heart's movespeed and lower One With All's AOE OR I WILL HAVE TO EAAAAATTT YOOOOOUUUU!!! 39 By Holy Shit 2007-02-24 ano to?? puro passive skill nya??
40 By tarheelfan83 2007-02-27 Umm...Here's the thing. You can never fully tell how a hero will do, or if he'll dominate, until you play him. We should really have some type of tester game where we can try the guy out. But at first impression, I'd have to say: No way. This hero would completely dominate and make games no fun. I agree with others when they ask, why upgrade the ULT? Even with the ULT AoE, and not the whole map. Has some promise, but needs to be toned down. 41 By Uros 2007-02-27 1st skill cool.Others not bad 42 By RUCrappingOnMyFace 2007-03-01 I love it. I wanna play it. NOW!!! 43 By Heretica 2007-03-08 well is a good hero but not for dota at least that ulti it takes all the purpose and the fun of ganging i think that that ability should be an active like naix with his rage. 44 By Bard Man 2007-03-15 Ok. To begin, you should just separate the Quiet Stike Bash/Crit and make Silent Heart your ult. This way, you would't have to tone it dow too much. also, why did you put so many passives into that one skill if it wasn't gonna be the ult?! Seriously, that would fix this guy but good. Now I'm gonna beg you DotA makers, after this guy gets finished, please make him a hero in the new version!! 45 By hiromico 2007-03-16 Suggestion...... if a hero targets him then that would trigger the ulti..... so he can only escape during the last seconds before gang bang..... just a suggestion 46 By Azxerion 2007-03-26 COOL !! i like this hero ! playing with no mana can make an unusual environment of play, worth trying 47 By terrorsinz 2007-03-26 This hero's first skill increased ms is almost same as night stalker's ulti-ims.
48 By 7_Seas 2007-04-16 All these passive auras would make him a great newb character. However, the obsidian destroyer would be completely ridiculous. The ultimate should be activated; I know it kinda hurts the character idea of not having control over the magic, but in the case of a large melee, it could mean megafacepwnage on this hero. 49 By Undercover13 2007-06-11 3000 AOE?!?!?!?!?!? No!!!! Extremely imba... If you want to make this ulti a little bit more NORMAL you should either make the AOE increase 400/600/700 or increase the dmg taken to 800 (or sth like that) to make it easy for your hero to actually be killed!!! 50 By dota_gamerz 2007-07-25 No Mana?? It sucks... 51 By ubernoob 2007-08-09 silent heart to imba imo. also i suggest that the final work like a radar that pings the enemy, revealing them for a few secs, it could be put on auto cast with a deminishing cooldown per level. say 20/15/10????
52 By ubernoob 2007-08-09 p.s. like the idea of all passive hero 53 By Faust the Dark Knight 2007-09-05 Too imba... 3rd skill's bash effect is great, but the 2nd effect of the 3rd skill is imba... I mean' comeon! 15% chancee to do 2.25 crit? it's more powerful than Buriza!! Lower the damage multiplier.. Other than that nice hero.. 54 By Krazhmir 2007-09-30 c_r_a_c_k wrote this
55 By hobos4president 2007-10-22 very neat idea for a hero, interesting to see how he would hold his own in a game. 56 By OceanPwntage 2007-10-24 well u know he can just get energy booster fellow commenters, and also creator, make it like when hes dead everything the enemy heroes can see without the scourge creeps should be shown to your team. 57 By Cloudzstrife 2007-12-12 So all your skills are passive? then his first skill is imba 35 increase mvoement and atk speed. Too much! 58 By TheWrathofGod 2007-12-14 all passive skillz 59 By phelanij 2008-03-05 c_r_a_c_k wrote this
60 By mortredcoupdegrace 2008-03-28 oww, don't have any active skill ??
61 By Doctrine 2008-04-23 This hero should have atleast one active skill..How could you counter Nortrom the silencer's curse of the silent w/o casting spell. He'll just keep on draining your life to death. 62 By PapaProtoss 2008-05-29 Silent Heart is imba. I would give him mana and very little INT because he can't use items such as dagon, mekansm... I also would negate slowing in wordless defence and he should be ok 63 By d3ath1sf0r3v3r 2008-08-02 i rly dont like heros with so many passives... point click kill heros like these kinda bore the player too 64 By folechno 2008-08-08 very nice backgorund story, liked it very much
65 By folechno 2008-08-08 heal is to powerful, compare to razor's unholy aura, this one rapes it in all areas and has even more effects
66 By folechno 2008-08-08 this ability
67 By folechno 2008-08-08 click and kill, already used by heroes such as Troll and Void
68 By folechno 2008-08-08 items
69 By folechno 2008-08-08 tower diving potential, especialy with Vanguard
70 By BloodFreaker 2008-08-10 WTH!!?!!?No intel???Totally unbalanced...This will cause the game to be ruined...IMO give this hero some intel(even it is very less)..like tat it will be more better..and also the 1st skill is a bit imba,MS plus 30%?!?this hero will hav like perma haste-like speed??otherwise i tink it's a good idea 71 By folechno 2008-08-12 and now for the rest of my comments
72 By folechno 2008-08-12 just because other people maphack does not mean that you should create a hero that can mh for free
73 By X-mild 2008-11-10 Harbringer can kill you with 1 sanity eclipse
|
||||||||||||||||||||
| DotaStrategy.com . Dota Allstars Hero Idea: Whisper - Voiceless Soldier | Blog - Downloads - About - Help |
Warcraft III: Reign of Chaos & Warcraft III: Frozen Throne are trademarks
and Blizzard Entertainment is a trademark or registered trademark of Blizzard
Entertainment in the U.S. and/or other countries. All Rights Reserved.
DotA Allstars is a trademark of Dota-Allstars.com All Rights Reserved.
DotA Strategy is a production of Alleba.com
Privacy Policy - ©2008 DotaStrategy.com All Rights Reserved.
DotA Allstars is a trademark of Dota-Allstars.com All Rights Reserved.
DotA Strategy is a production of Alleba.com
Privacy Policy - ©2008 DotaStrategy.com All Rights Reserved.

(Arcane Orb = +400 damage to summoned units!) So in DOTA there are NOT EVERY HERO EQUALENT!!! Anyway, I like the idea of the Voiceless Soldier...